Decision Simulator

Artemis — The Hatch Left Open

Artemis
Fishing vessel · Kilkeel Harbour, Northern Ireland · 29 April 2019
Source: MAIB Report 1/2020

3Decision Points 3Possible Outcomes Avg. Play Time

The Situation

You're the skipper of a fishing vessel moored at Kilkeel Harbour for the night. As you secure the boat before turning in, you notice the mess deck hatch is open for ventilation, as it usually is — but since a modification to the boat's layout, the access route to the toilet now passes directly over it.

The Lesson

Layout modifications that create new hazards in crew movement areas must be risk-assessed and fitted with physical safeguards. Familiarity with a hazard is not the same as managing it.

Human Element

The open hatch had become an accepted feature of the vessel through repeated, incident-free familiarity, and the post-build layout change that routed the access path directly over it was never formally risk-assessed after the modification was made.

Try the First Decision

The hatch has always been left open overnight for ventilation. Now the route to the toilet crosses directly over it in the dark.

A. Close or guard the hatch before anyone turns in, given the route now crosses right over it
B. Leave the hatch open as always — it's always been fine before

This is a preview — the full scenario branches from here based on what you choose, with real consequences and a debrief at the end.

Play the Full Scenario — Free

Create a free profile to play this scenario through to the end, with a full human-factors debrief. No card required.

Create Free Profile & Play →