All Sectors

Three Die as Nicola Faith Capsizes in Colwyn Bay — Overloaded Vessel's Stability Exhausted

🕑 5 min read words Safety • Incident

Vessel: Nicola Faith (BS58) — 10.7m steel whelk potter fishing vessel
Date & location: 27 January 2021, Colwyn Bay, North Wales
Outcome: Vessel capsized and sank. All three crew — skipper Russell Smith, and crew members Carl McGrath and Michael Lewis — lost
Human factors: Normalisation · Complacency · Workload
Source: MAIB Report 8/2022

6 decision points2 outcome paths — reduce load and escape / carry on and go over~8 min read + Knowledge Checker

4.6 Tonnes

On the morning of 27 January 2021, the whelk potter Nicola Faith capsized and sank in Colwyn Bay. All three crew were lost. The investigation found the vessel was carrying an estimated 4.6 tonnes of catch and pots on deck — a load that had eliminated its remaining positive stability. The capsize was sudden.

Two features of the vessel compounded the danger. A plywood deck canopy, fitted over the working area to improve conditions for the crew, trapped them below when the vessel went over. And the port whelk hold could not be accessed from inside the vessel after capsize, because its cover was closed. No formal stability assessment had been carried out since modifications were made to the vessel. None of the three crew were wearing personal flotation devices.

The Warnings That Were Already There

Nicola Faith had listed excessively and shipped water before this trip. Those events should have been read as direct evidence that the vessel was operating beyond its safe parameters. Instead, operations continued unchanged — the previous incidents were absorbed as one-off occurrences rather than treated as a pattern demanding action. The decision to keep loading heavily was made in a commercial context, maximising the catch on a working boat. The consequence was the loss of three lives.

Recommended Actions

The MAIB made recommendations to the MCA, the Welsh Government, and the fishing industry addressing stability monitoring and overloading risk in small fishing vessels. The findings point every skipper and owner of a small potter or creeler toward the same practical steps:

Know your vessel's maximum safe load in its current configuration — and check what's actually on deck against it before you sail, not by feel
Treat any deck modification that could obstruct escape — a canopy, an additional structure, a covering — as requiring a formal safety review before it's fitted, not after
Treat any incident of listing or water-shipping as a direct trigger to reassess loading and stability, not as a one-off to note and continue past
Keep a current, formal stability assessment for the vessel, and review it whenever the vessel's configuration or loading pattern changes
Wear a PFD on deck at all times — not stowed below, where it does no good in the seconds a sudden capsize allows

Human Element Analysis

Normalisation

Overloading and listing had happened before without a capsize, so the practice continued. A pattern that hasn't yet produced a disaster starts to feel like a workable routine rather than a risk that's still live every single time it's repeated.

Complacency

The plywood canopy was fitted to make the working deck more comfortable. Its effect on escape routes in a capsize was never assessed, because a structural addition made for crew welfare wasn't seen as something that needed a safety review in its own right.

Workload

Maximising the day's catch was the commercial pressure driving the load decision. On a small working boat, the trade-off between one more pot of whelks and the vessel's remaining stability margin isn't visible in the moment — there's no gauge on deck reading out 'zero positive stability remaining.'

How This Pattern Repeats

Industry	Incident	The parallel
Aviation	Fine Air Flight 101, 1997	Incorrectly loaded cargo shifted the aircraft's centre of gravity aft of safe limits, causing an uncontrollable pitch-up at rotation and the loss of the aircraft — overloading eliminating a safety margin the crew had no direct way of seeing until it was too late, exactly as it did on Nicola Faith.
Offshore	Alexander L. Kielland platform capsize, 1980	A structural weakness present since construction went unaddressed until a leg failed in a storm and the platform capsized, killing 123 — a known vulnerability allowed to persist because nothing had gone wrong with it yet.
Rail	Grayrigg derailment, UK, 2007	A known-defective set of points was left in service through a gap in the maintenance inspection regime, derailing a train travelling at speed — a warning sign (the points' documented deterioration) that existed but wasn't acted on in time.

See How You'd Handle It

The scenario opens on deck, mid-haul, with the pots stacking up faster than the hold is emptying. Do you call it and head in, or keep loading for one more good haul? Six decision points follow, ending where Nicola Faith's stability ran out.

What Every Skipper Should Take From This

Overloading a small fishing vessel is a life-safety decision, not a commercial one — whatever context it's made in
Any structural addition that changes how crew escape the working deck needs its own safety assessment before it's fitted
A vessel that has listed or shipped water before has already told you something — the second warning is rarely the last one you get
Stability has to be assessed formally and kept current, not estimated by how the boat feels on the day
A PFD stowed below does nothing in a sudden capsize — wear it on deck, every time

Test Your Knowledge

Think you've got this covered? Put it to the test in Crew Connect's free Knowledge Checker — try a quick safety round and see how you score.