All Sectors

Four Minutes: Why Sandy Alexander Didn't Survive a Grounding Most Crews Would Have Walked Away From

🕑 5 min read words Safety • Incident

Vessel: Lexi Rose (BF 370), 7.29m aluminium single-hulled creel fishing vessel, built 1990
Date & location: 21 September 2023, Melrose Point, near Macduff, Aberdeenshire, Scotland
Outcome: Grounded and capsized approximately 4 minutes after propulsion loss. Skipper Sandy Alexander (69) declared deceased — drowning, following a significant head injury sustained in the capsize
Human factors: Normalisation · Situational Awareness · Complacency
Source: MAIB Report 4/2025

6 decision points2 outcome paths — prepared / unprepared~7 min read + Knowledge Checker

Four Minutes Is Not Long Enough to Improvise

On 21 September 2023, Sandy Alexander left Banff harbour at 08:37 to work his creel pots east of Macduff, as he had done for years. He was 69, had skippered commercial vessels for over 40 years, and knew these waters better than almost anyone. The forecast was Force 5, with a 1-metre residual swell — workable conditions he'd handled many times before. At 10:51 he spoke by phone with the skipper of a nearby vessel, Chance; they agreed the conditions were fine and decided to work as a loose pair for mutual support.

At approximately 11:09, while transiting between creel locations at 3–5 knots, the outboard engine's lower assembly unit struck an underwater rock. The shearing force fractured the unit from the engine casing. Propulsion was gone, instantly, with Lexi Rose already close inshore in the swell.

What MAIB Found

Sandy made two VHF calls — not on channel 16, the international distress frequency, but on channel 12, the local working channel: “Lifeboat, lifeboat, lifeboat. We're ashore, engine stopped, need a lifeboat,” then, moments later, “I need a lifeboat, she's going, she's going.” Lexi Rose grounded and capsized in a small cove at the base of Melrose Point. From propulsion loss to grounding took around four minutes.

The skipper of Chance reached the cove at 11:12 but couldn't enter due to draught. A member of the public alerted the coastguard at 11:16. The inshore lifeboat arrived at 11:37, but couldn't enter the cove either. At 12:00, the coastguard helicopter located Sandy floating in the water, five metres from the upturned hull, unconscious, not wearing a PFD. He was winched aboard and declared deceased during the flight to Aberdeen.

The postmortem found the cause of death was a significant head injury and drowning. Sandy was a non-swimmer who owned a PFD but chose not to wear it that day.

What MAIB Actually Concluded

MAIB made no formal recommendations in this case — not because nothing went wrong, but because the investigation found existing MCA guidance (PFD wearing, DSC distress procedure, single-handed operation risk) already covered everything that would have changed the outcome. Instead, MAIB issued a safety flyer to the fishing industry and drew a direct comparison to a near-identical prior loss: Anna-Marie II (MAIB 12/2020), where the skipper also drowned after a head injury during capsize, also without a PFD.

Recommended Actions

Not new recommendations — the existing guidance MAIB pointed to as already sufficient, if it's actually followed:

Wear a PFD at all times at sea — mandatory under MSN 1871 Amendment No.2(F) on commercial fishing vessels under 15m since 2018, not optional for experienced skippers
Use DSC on VHF channel 16 for distress, not a local working channel — a single button press sends vessel identity and GPS position directly to the coastguard
Register any EPIRB/PLB with the MCA Beacon Registry, and carry it on the body, not stowed in the wheelhouse
For single-handed operation, pre-position your response to a sudden propulsion loss before you need it — there may not be time to improvise one

Human Element Analysis

Normalisation

Sandy had fished these waters for years and chose Lexi Rose specifically for close-inshore access. MAIB found he had “become used to the hazards of working close inshore” and likely didn't fully appreciate how fast the situation could escalate. Hundreds of uneventful trips in the same conditions had quietly redefined what “normal risk” looked like.

Situational Awareness

There was no warning that the outboard's lower assembly unit — the deepest point of the vessel, projecting 150mm below the keel — was about to strike anything. Once it did, propulsion loss was total and immediate, with no secondary system, in water Sandy had transited many times without incident.

Complacency

An occasional PFD-wearer, not a consistent one. A PLB carried, but unregistered and stowed in the wheelhouse rather than worn. Distress calls made on a familiar local channel rather than DSC channel 16. Each of these choices was individually minor and each had worked out fine before — until the day they all had to work at once, in four minutes, alone.

How This Pattern Repeats

Industry	Incident	The parallel
Space	Apollo 1 fire, 1967	A pure-oxygen test environment with known fire risk had been run the same way many times before — familiarity had normalised a hazard that was still fully present the day it killed three astronauts on the ground.
Offshore / Petrochemical	BP Texas City refinery explosion, 2005	Investigators found years of incident-free operation had normalised known unsafe practices at the site — the same erosion of perceived risk through repeated success that MAIB identified in Sandy's close-inshore working pattern.
Aviation	John F. Kennedy Jr. crash, 1999	A single operator, on a familiar route, in deteriorating conditions, with no second person to catch a developing problem — the same structural vulnerability of single-handed operation that left Sandy with no one to anchor, call, or don a PFD for him.

See How You'd Handle It

The scenario opens at the moment of propulsion loss, close inshore, in swell, alone. You have roughly four minutes. Do you reach for the PFD first, the DSC button, or the anchor? Six decision points follow, ending at the same cove MAIB investigated.

What Every Single-Handed Operator Should Take From This

PFD on your body before you leave harbour — not a rule for other people, not something you'll do “if it looks rough”
Know your vessel's single point of failure — for Lexi Rose it was the outboard's lower assembly unit, 150mm below the keel
DSC on channel 16 reaches the coastguard directly with your position; a local working channel does not
A PLB in the wheelhouse is a PLB you can't reach if you go over the side — wear it
Familiar water is not safe water — it's water where you've been lucky so far